Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums


How Microsoft can salvage Windows 8 before it's too late

  1. #101


    Posts : 299
    win 7 home premium 64 bit


    Quote Originally Posted by Mike Lonewolf View Post
    R0bR, I seriously doubt that. I myself use the start menu, I hate a desktop, and taskbar polluted with icons, It's just messy, and as the saying goes, a messy desktop makes a messy mind.
    Same here.


    I constantly use start search and menu during the day. I also dislike a "cluttered" desktop or screen filled with short cuts.
    Even my task bar is pretty clean.

    I also fall into the catagory of people that unfortunately don't tend to give feedback often and sometimes get flustered when asked about my opinion, as if anyone cares. Well considering MS attitude of " Go Metro or Go Linux Mint" , I figured I will go with Mint. Why should I have to fight with a company to provide options I'd like (that can EASILY be made available) when I can just Go...with Linux Mint. The best thing is it is FREE!

    MS You are going to LOSE a LOT of your best customers, who also were often times your best sales people, offering positive comments about XP, 7, and even Vista after you sorted it fully, which helped to make a few more sales for you. Multiply those referrals by millions and you received a LOT of additional business due to our recommendations (say over OSX)


    Alas now MS has decided to go over to the "dark side" and follow the obnoxious lead of Apple.

    We can only hope that when the RTM version appears that sanity has returned to MS and they WILL allow the customer the OPTION to select a default configuration of Boot To Desktop for those of us that have stuck with MS all these years through the good and the bad.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #102


    Australia
    Posts : 716
    Windows 7 Ult Reatil & Win 8 Pro OEM


    Quote Originally Posted by R0bR View Post
    Approx. 90% of the worlds PC population runs Windows, even if only 5% of those users leave the default setting for Customer Experience Program checked it's a large enough sample size to make any statistical feedback Microsoft receives valid. However I'm sure the percentage is much higher than that.
    It's not the size of the sample. It's where the sampling is taken from.

    By default Customer Improvement Experience program is set to "no". Only persons positively wanting to send feedback would use it, which auto biases your sampling.

    This means huge blocks of users such as office workers, power users, etc, would never answer. To be valid the 5% would have to include a proportionately equal amount of users from each group making up the 100%. For example, if:

    Power users = 15%
    Home users= 20%
    Business personnel = 15%
    Educational institutes =15%
    Geeks = 15%
    IT personnel = 10%
    Defence Forces and Miscellaneous = 10%

    Total = 100%

    To make your results valid, your 5% sample would need to be made up of 15% of power users, 20% home users, etc. And they would ALL need to answer the question: "Do you use start menu or not?"

    And that is clearly not happening. Why would office workers for example want to do that? It doesn't directly concern them. All they care about is the fact that they've got a start menu. Take it away from them, and then you'll hear from. Which is what will happen when Win8 gets into business ... if it ever does!
    Last edited by Mustang; 31 Jul 2012 at 14:24.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #103


    Posts : 534
    Windows 7, Windows 8 RP


    Quote Originally Posted by Mustang View Post
    And they would ALL need to answer the question: "Do you use start menu or not?"
    Obviously you don't know how the Customer Experience Program works, if you accept to be part of it that's the last you'll see of it because everything happens behind the scenes. You're not asked questions, Windows automatically sends Microsoft information on how you're using the software. So yes, if you accept to partake you are indirectly answering how you use the start menu by your mouse clicks.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #104


    Posts : 5,360
    7/8/ubuntu/Linux Deepin


    That is exactly the point he is making.

    They don't ask - they go on telemetry.

    Example 1:

    Let us assume for this example that most sentences contain 30- 40 characters. Usually there is only one Capital letter.

    If you rely on Telemetry alone - you might conclude Capitals are only used two or three per cent of the time.

    It is pointless having them - hardly any use of them - let's get rid of them.

    Example 2:

    WDP is released.

    Let us assume:

    Telemetry indicates most users look at Metro for a short while. Then they use the registry hack to boot to desktop and never go near Metro after that.

    The response might be panic. Ripping out of code to force users repeatedly back to the start screen.

    There was no attempt to find out what the telemetry actually meant. No attempt to find out why the users were doing that. Most importantly , no attempt to find out how the users feel about that aspect of the product.

    No attempt to repond to the users wants and needs.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #105


    Posts : 51
    Windows 8 pre-release


    Quote Originally Posted by SIW2 View Post
    That is exactly the point he is making.

    They don't ask - they go on telemetry.
    The implication being, of course, that Microsoft and everything they do is evil. This is a pyrrhic argument, 5% of which is based on the idea that you are calling "telemetry" and 95% based in Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt regarding an Orwellian concept of how the business world operates.

    It's a little like acting like spoiled little children who, after receiving a toy or plaything for free now insist that they are being abused because they have not been granted the expensive wonderful toy that they "really wanted."

    Isn't Windows a product and is this not a free market economy? Nobody is forcing anybody to do anything and I'm fairly certain that no coders are ripping apart major portions of the OS based on this evil machination of "cookie and bug" recording.

    By painting MS as an evil big brother bent on our destruction, I think we are missing a golden opportunity to participate in the creation of a system (that you correctly say is the only option). Anger and FUD hurts us, the users, not Microsoft the service provider. Ultimately, such inactive bleating will leave us as relevant as OS/2 and CP/M DOS (not that I don't greatly admire those two OS's and their coding standards).

    All of my copies of OS/2 are neatly stacked in a closet, preserved until such a time when IBM allows the code to be open sourced to the OS/2 community. Guess what? I'll be waiting for this forever and I'll be a sentimental about my OS/2 graveyard. I don't even want to talk of the virtues of CP/M and how it was cruelly supplanted by the evil Windows 95.

    I think it would be nicer if we could reframe this argument in a way that says:

    "If MS does ABC or releases a product with PQR features and an XYZ development Kit, I will do something I am capable of doing. Life will go on. I will be productive, earn money and do what I like to do!"
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #106


    Posts : 5,360
    7/8/ubuntu/Linux Deepin


    Evil?

    LOL somebody has been watching star wars again.

    Anger? Bleating?

    A little fanciful to put it mildly.

    It is fascinating to watch.

    I don't know how it will turn out - there are so many factors - many of them not in MS control.

    Fun to watch a large monoploy trying something risky.

    Surprising they are breaking the rules and making it harder for themselves.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #107


    Posts : 5,360
    7/8/ubuntu/Linux Deepin


    Might surprise you to know that yesterday I was hired to work on a campaign for one of the biggest names in coffee.

    It is one of the things I do.

    It interests me.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #108


    Posts : 51
    Windows 8 pre-release


    Quote Originally Posted by SIW2 View Post
    Evil?

    I don't know how it will turn out - there are so many factors - many of them not in MS control.

    Fun to watch a large monoploy trying something risky.

    Surprising they are breaking the rules and making it harder for themselves.
    Thou sayest.

    I'm saying that sentimental arguments are not helping to move things forward. When you create broad generalizations like "the Monopoly," or "something risky" you are indicating an unwillingness to think. Your false condescension is meant to be humorous but it indicates your need for a sheepish following.

    Microsoft has never HAD a monopoly. What happened with Vista N in the greatest UNIX market on Earth (EU)? It was a disaster but it proved that MS had no monopoly in Europe. What are the "Rules" you speak of?

    Microsoft does have the largest market share (5% for Vista, 39 for XP and 51% for 7)and they will keep it until someone stops complaining and builds something better (i.e. OS X, AROS, IRIX, HP/UX or some other system). Then, that party will be your "Monopoly" and you will pillory them.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #109


    Posts : 5,360
    7/8/ubuntu/Linux Deepin


    Childish posturing?

    I am discussing marketing - those who do not understand are not forced to reply.

    Seems to me that you are the one getting angry.

    Name calling will not be tolerated .
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  10. #110


    Australia
    Posts : 716
    Windows 7 Ult Reatil & Win 8 Pro OEM


    Quote Originally Posted by R0bR View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Mustang View Post
    And they would ALL need to answer the question: "Do you use start menu or not?"
    Obviously you don't know how the Customer Experience Program works, if you accept to be part of it ...
    Exactly! That's the whole point. You have totally ignored what I said. I know how Customer Experience works, but because it's set to "NO" by default, the vast majority of users aren't going to turn it on. So their "mouse click" votes are never registered!

    This includes huge blocks of users such as office workers where probably 90% would vote yes, but don't because it's not turned on. So the sample is biased.

    I worked in the Bureau of Census and Statistics. Ring them or any dept of stats at any university, and put the facts to them, and they will tell you exactly what I'm telling you. It's a non valid sampling method.

    Quote Originally Posted by rich4421972
    ***
    No amount of rhetoric promoting Win8 in forums will change the reality of how the public will react. But if there are enough protests, it might get Microsoft's attention. However, the main protest will come from consumers in the market place, and that will definitely get their attention! And the reaction will not be proactive, but rather by their omission in not using W8 in the business sector and many other sectors.

    If you check around other forums you will observe a huge outcry against the dropping of the start menu. IMHO MS can ignore that at their own peril. No company is so big it can afford to ignore the preferences of it's clientelle. What they're doing is almost inviting another player to step up to the mark. And someone like Google have the resources to do just that; and have already tested the water with Android. Plus there are many others hovering around the fringes.

    And since comnpetition is the life blood of a market based economy, that wouldn't be such a bad thing, with the main beneficiaries being the consumrer. MS have had it their own way far too long in the lower end of the PC market.

    Putting all that aside, we won't really know the final outcome until at least SP1 is released. From a stats point of view I'd wager a bet that the probablility of it being returned is very, very high..
    Last edited by Mustang; 01 Aug 2012 at 22:17.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 11 of 25 FirstFirst ... 91011121321 ... LastLast
How Microsoft can salvage Windows 8 before it's too late
Related Threads
Solved Howto salvage Win 8 Pro on a SSD in Installation & Setup
I have come to the conclusion my 115 gb ssd is failing. Windows can't restore from a restore point and paragon partition recovery could not finish. Several of my programs will expire and I don't want to lose them. If I reinstall Win 8 Pro with custom option onto my hdd will my programs...
Solved Sorry MicroSoft, it's to late, in General Support
Yep, it to late to teach this old dog new tricks, i upgraded to win 8, spent 4 hours trying to learn new tricks. solved the problem,I installed " Classic Shell" and now I am the proud owner of windows 7 & 1/2....... works pretty damn good.
Read more at source: Microsoft to deliver new Windows 8 and Windows RT Lync app in late October | ZDNet
Read more at: Windows 8 to arrive by late October, Microsoft says | Windows 8 - CNET Reviews
Windows 8 tablets too late ? in General Support
I just finished a quote for a high school, they want a wireless network for their 632 students that will use Ipad instead of text book and pen. They make the experience last year with 1 class and was extremely satisfy. Apple offer the Ipad at discount for the parents. It's not unique here in...
more at source...
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook