Yep, I have a
long, strange history with Memtest with the original memory I had installed. I was hoping we wouldn't get to that point in the discussion yet
When I first built this machine in 2010, I did extensive memory testing. In a bizarre, unsolved mystery, every time I did a cold boot (
from Windows only, not Ubuntu or direct from MemTest), I would pass Memtest. Every time I did a reboot into Memtest, I would fail, usually within a couple of minutes, but sometimes only after several hours. This was repeatable and consistent, and the only way to pass MemTest was to reboot from something non-Windows, or to turn off/on the PSU.
I tried removing/replacing every single part, down to the PSU, with the exception of the Mobo and CPU (which I think I reseated), but nothing fixed my issue. Seems like there is a decent chance I have a bad mobo, which at this point I will live with, rather than rebuild the whole dang thing from scratch with a new mobo that will have its own set of compatibility issues with the rest of the hardware, which is 4-5 yrs old at this point.
I have these periodic failures, which up til now have just been a pain (when I was on Win 7, I would just get a glitch where a bunch of services would crash and restart, including my UI Theme service, so I would see a visual change, but after 60 secs everything was back to normal. But these pretty, Win 8 pale BSODs are new and I suspect are aggravated by something I have done recently.
I did upgrade RAM recently, so it's possible that if I test now I will get Memtest errors due to the actual memory being faulty. Can't rule that out, but it's hard to prove that that's the case, since Memtest has always failed for me (maybe I can try some cold boot testing with the new memory, since it should fail that if it's actually faulty).