Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

Microsoft Admits MSE is Just Basic Protection

  1. #11

    Arnhem, The Netherlands
    Posts : 1,412
    Windows 8.1 Pro x64 Media Center Edition

    Quote Originally Posted by Ron AKA View Post
    I read the article a little bit differently. I think there are two key points which have implications that need to be fully understood.

    1. Microsoft is giving away all their knowledge of legitimate virus threats to the competition.

    2. Microsoft is focusing their efforts on responding to real viruses in the wild, instead of spending a lot of time and money trying to predict how virus software will be tested by professional anti virus testing companies (like the one in the article).

    What are the implications? Microsoft will not be able to beat the competition by keeping information they know about secret. The consumer however will benefit as external AV companies will not have a weak product. And MS will not be embarrassed by attacks on their software due to weak external AV software.

    If external companies take the MS info gratis, and then spend their time/$$ predicting how their software will be tested, they of course will come out of any simulated testing program on top.

    Does this mean the MS AV software is bad? I don't think so. I want software to protect me against real viruses, not ones that in effect are created to make the AV software look good. The AV software companies and the AV software testing companies have a bit of a self dealing game going on...

    Just my thoughts

    First of all I've had to read the article twice. English is not my native tongue, but I can't believe that this article is written in proper English.

    Secondly, I concur with "Ron AKA". Microsoft is putting their effort in batteling the real virusses instead of pimping the outcome of a specific test.

    I'll keep on using MSE .



      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #12

    Posts : 529
    Windows 8.1 Pro

    I got my answer i'm going to stick with Windows defender i have never had a issue. when i get one then i will switch but for now it works.
    Last edited by TonyB; 04 Oct 2013 at 16:28.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #13

    Posts : 375
    Win 8.1 64bit

    Everyone can make their best choice. The article does state that Microsoft recommends a 3rd party AV. Also, Microsoft shares info with AV companies to protect their OS and does not compete for superiority in the AV field.

    Another review posted on Softpedia.

    Microsoft Security Essentials (MSE) represents Microsoft's initiative to offer a free antivirus to users who do not want to pay for such a service, while still taking advantage of powerful features. It includes a real-time guard against various types of malware, like viruses, spyware, Trojans and rootkits.

    The application offers support for Windows XP, Vista and 7, whereas Windows Defender is the built-in av program in Windows 8 (they share the same virus definitions). Although it is widely regarded as entry-level security software, MSE has some advanced settings under the hood
    The Good

    Microsoft Security Essentials implements a shell extension for scanning custom files, folders or drives when exploring the computer. The real-time guard can be disabled from the Settings panel. The interface is incredibly easy for novices to figure out. Resources usage is generally low when the real-time layer is activated and no scans are running.

    The Bad

    The notification system is intrusive. Too many messages keep popping up from the bottom-right corner of the screen when no actions need to be taken. During tests, confirmation for cleaning the same threats was often requested by Security Essentials.

    When the tool is applying selected actions on infections, you cannot cancel the task, navigate MSE's interface or minimize the window. The progress bar in the “Potential threat details” panel is frequently misleading when removing or quarantining files, aside from the fact that the job takes too long. It starts filling the meter rapidly and progressively decreases in speed.

    The History tab does not include reports for each scan job, nor total scan time. Furthermore, it is not possible to schedule custom scans or definition updates, look for only particular file types, or specify the default action for real-time protection and scan methods individually.

    The Truth

    The bottom line is that MSE is a suitable security solution only for casual users who don't venture too often in the Internet's darkest corners. More advanced (or courageous) people will need to take the next rational step: upgrading to a more powerful product

    Microsoft Security Essentials Review (complete lengthy article)
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #14

    Posts : 529
    Windows 8.1 Pro

    not true i have a scheduled scan setup and it runs when i want it see here ----->Windows Defender Scheduled Scan - Set Up in Windows 8
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #15

    Portsmouth Hants
    Posts : 772
    Windows 8.1 Pro with Media Center

    I always felt that MSE was just an extension of Microsoft's anti-piracy program, and basically did very little unless a keygen or suchlike was detected. Malware just passed right through, and you needed Malwarebytes regularly to catch BHO and PUP malware. If you are unlucky enough, Malwarebytes will quarantine almost everything in your Windows folders that Windows Defender had let in and require a reinstall.

    With Windows 8 Microsoft feel they have conquered the loader and SLIC workarounds that plagued Windows 7, and therefore will not put any more effort into antilmalware. With the demise of Technet etc., and software mostly distributed via the Store they just will not bother anymore.

    It's just MSAV all over again, MSE will just fail to be updated, and 3rd parties will supply the AV again.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #16

    Posts : 454
    Windows 8.1 Pro with Media Center

    How do you folks encounter malware and viruses and rootkits?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #17

    If they wished, Microsoft could have built and provided with Windows an AV product that rivaled the best commercial versions on the market. But there are a number of good reasons why they chose not to.

    1. If they had done so it would leave companies such as AVAST, AVG, AVIRA, Symantec, etc, without a market for their products. This issue has caused Microsoft a great deal of expensive legal trouble in the past. Thus they are constrained as to what they can provide with Windows.

    2. This may come as a surprise to some, but Microsoft does not have unlimited resources. They must chose where those limited resources will best serve both their customers and shareholders. Creating a good AV product takes a very considerable effort. And this is a market that is already well served with both commercial and free products. Microsoft chose to devote their efforts to the OS itself, a field that cannot be well served with third party products.

    You can recommend that people install a third party AV product, and Microsoft has done this. But most people won't. So it would seem a responsible thing to provide an AV product that provides "Basic protection." This minimizes the drain on resources and avoids legal problems.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #18

    Posts : 529
    Windows 8.1 Pro

    go here they all discuss how this add was taken way out of context. News from Microsoft (PCPRO Article - MSE) - Microsoft Community
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #19

    [QUOTE=torre;2856 The article does state that Microsoft recommends a 3rd party AV. Also, Microsoft shares info with AV companies to protect their OS and does not compete for superiority in the AV field.[/QUOTE]

    Here is a link to a more complete report of the story. Where does it say in actual quotation marks, i.e. real words spoken by Holly Stewart, that Microsoft recommends a third party AV. To that issue, she did say:

    "Baseline does not equal bad," she said. "We provide a high-quality, high-performing service to our customers and if they choose not to buy [antivirus] on Windows 8... we want to get those people protected."
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  10. #20

    Quote Originally Posted by Phone Man View Post
    From what I have seen at AV-TEST and AV-Comparatives they don't create viruses but use what is found in the wild and try and use a wide selection to fairly test AV systems. So to say it is "rigged" is just BS.
    So, you wouldn't mind having John McAfee as your neighbor, and lend him your wheelbarrow, if he asked for it...

    Click image for larger version
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails 21.01.FF_.McAfee.DL_.59838.Wired_McAfee__039.jpg  
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Microsoft Admits MSE is Just Basic Protection
Related Threads
Just threw the consumer preview of windows 8 on an old desktop that was previously running 7, and now I can't get it to recognize my graphics card. It's just an integrated AMD chip, the Radeon X200. I found a copy of the legacy drivers for vista online and ran the installer in compatibility mode,...
I have installed windows 8.1 on my Dell dimension 9150. I have all of the drivers apart from my graphics card driver because it isn't supported in Windows 8.1. Is is there any way I can set the resolution to 1366x768 without a driver?
Running Windows 8.1 Preview x64. I was attempting to update my graphics drivers on my Vaio SE2C5E using those provided here. Things were already a bit messed up before hand, with the switchable graphics ability randomly disappearing one day. Thinking that I was uninstalling the existing drivers I...
Hey guys, I have nc6400, with ati mobility radeon x1300 and 6 hours ago I've installed win 8.First I wanted to encounter graphics card problem. It doesn't recognize card, it just says Microsoft Basic Display Adapter. I tried updating it with Browse and let me pick option, but without any success....
Just a poll to see how people have their MAPS option set within Windows Defender. Do you have it not joined, Basic or Advanced?
Hi everyone. I have installed Windows 8 onto my Inspiron 1501 notebook. The installation was good, but when I ran the digital adivsor for Media Center I receive an error message saying the display driver has to be updated. I looked in the device manager and the it is the microsoft basic display...
Read more at source: Microsoft admits Surface keyboard splitting problem | ZDNet
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook