Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

Clone vs Image

  1. #1


    Posts : 4
    Windows 10

    Clone vs Image


    Hello Everyone,
    Can u help to explain these two things, Image vs Clone.
    -Which one that we should use to prevent Hard Drive failture or Windows stop working?
    Thanks

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2


    From a response on a forum:
    Clone means a track by track copy including empty ones. Usually used to copy one disk directly to another. Image only saves used tracks and not the empty ones. Used to keep a smaller backup to be restored later.
    I have Macrium Reflect and do Image backups of the entire disc (all partitions). I do not do incremental backups, only full drive backups.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3


    I also use Macrium but I do incremental image backups. Either method will work.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4


    N. Calif
    Posts : 2,593
    W10 Pro (desktop), W10 (laptop), W10 Pro (tablet), W10 (laptop)


    Quote Originally Posted by veasnayim View Post
    Hello Everyone,
    Can u help to explain these two things, Image vs Clone.
    -Which one that we should use to prevent Hard Drive failture or Windows stop working?
    Thanks
    Neither will prevent hard drive failure or prevent Windows from working but either can be used to backup a drive so that things can be restored in the event of a drive or Windows failure.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5


    Image is in case you incrementally backed up a virus or some other form of scumware on the original image. If that happened, you would still have the original image for restoration purposes without having to reinstall Windows and all of the other applications that have accumulated on your hard drive. Cloning a drive is useful to upgrade your hard drive or clone a failing drive to a new one. The only issue is that you need to have two drives in the same computer unless you have an USB hard drive . If you accidentally pick the new empty drive, and clone that to the original drive, you will totally overwrite all of your data. No getting it back, it’s gone. So I recommend using EaseUS Todo Backup imaging process to upgrade a hard drive. It is a safety measure as well.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #6


    Disadvantages to a clone:
    When you make a clone of your main HD, it will totally occupy the 'To' disk.
    But, when you make an image of your C: drive, for instance, to a separate HD, of sufficient size, then you can store multiple images, which is good if one image goes bad on you.

    Personally, I like the idea of doing an Image Backup of my C: drive once a week, to a second internal HD, and also to an external 1TB, USB 3.0 hard drive.

    "The only bad backup, is the one you decided NOT to make". All others will have some merit.

    But remember...... if your main HD totally crashes, your Restore program MUST be on some bootable media, like a CD or Flash Drive.
    A Backup & Restore program that totally lives on drive C: , is totally worthless, in case of a HD crash.

    Cheers Mate!
    TechnoMage
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #7


    UK
    Posts : 275
    Windows 8.1 64 bit


    I recently wanted to move my OS from a HDD to a SSD and was advised to image the disk rather than clone when using Macrium Reflect. I was advised that cloning might duplicate the disk signature and I might end up with 2 disks with the same signatures.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Clone vs Image
Related Threads
My last laptop had W7 dual booted with Linux (Mint Cinnamon 17.1), each in a partition. I'd clone them both on a regular basis with Clonezilla. Nice and simple. My new laptop is a Lenovo with W8.1 - UEFI of course. I've managed to dual boot it as well, but I'm having a problem with cloning W8.1 -...
Solved Image or Clone with Macrium? in Performance & Maintenance
I have created an image of my desktop W8.1 and the small partition before it with Macrium Reflect Free Edition. I have decided that instead of using the current 2.5" older SATA II SSD that I was going to use an mSATA (SATA III) as my boot drive. After the creation of the desktop image I noticed the...
Clone from SSD to HDD in Installation & Setup
Hi, I am hoping someone can give me some advice. I recently bought a new laptop and I want to take the SSD from my old laptop and put it in my new one. Normally not a problem but I have a lot on my SSD that I still want to be able to use on the old laptop so I was trying to clone it so I...
Clone or move W-7 and or 8 to new SSD in Installation & Setup
My system is a dual boot Widows 8.1, (default) and Windows 7 Pro on a partitioned 1TB. I want to keep the dual boot config but move my W-8 which is about all I use to a new Crucial M500 SSD,120GB and keep the 7 on the older drive, along with most of my data files. Am I dreaming or is something...
Solved Want to clone HDD for laptops in Installation & Setup
I don't know if this can be done, so I am bringing it to this forum. I recently purchased 3 identical Gateway laptop computers to set-up and ship to relatives overseas. All three are running Windows 8. I want each one of them to have the same programs and applications without spend hours or days...
Hi there I always thought that CLONE Disk really did Clone disks - however this doesn't seem to be exactly the case. I decided to upgrade a SAMSUNG 830 120 GB SSD to a Samsung 840 250 GB SSD in a laptop recently. The cloning process went fine -- I left the partitions EXACTLY as they were on the...
Solved It can't be done! W8 clone to factory in Installation & Setup
Prove me wrong. Please. But I have spent enormous time (wasted) on trying to clone an Asus 750GB HDD to a Seagate 750GB SSD+HDD Hybrid. I've tried numerous free programs & various BIOS settings and have failed everytime. My simple goal was to take this original hard drive and just clone it to the...
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook