Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

i5 Extracting and WinRar

  1. #1

    i5 Extracting and WinRar


    Hello, I guess I'm sort of a newbie when it comes to the whole quad core processor thing that i5's and i7's have.

    When extracting files with WinRar, one file will go quickly, but when I extract two at the same time, it slows down.

    I thought the whole thing with i5 was to be able to run two things at the same time at same speeds?

    Why does the extracting slow down on both?

    Am I not understanding how the quad processors work?

    Thanks in Advance!

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2


    Some of the multi-processor (personally) is myth. However doing two things at the same time with the same program (e.g. unzipping files) can potentially be a problem.

    Multi-tasking (doing more than one thing at a time) is standard basic PC operation, whether its a single core processor or multi-core. Most processor threads (cores) are controlled by the OS, however an application can also take advantage of multi-cores if it is designed for that. For example, I use Sonar recording studio software. The older versions only left the core selection and processing to the OS, the latest version takes advantage of the multi-core capabilites and does some selection within the program.


    But to answer your question, I don't see any difference on most programs between the old Q6600 CPU system I had and the new systems I have - one with an i7 3770 and the other with an i5 3550. They do basically load and process a little faster as I have SSD drives, but many programs - to the naked eye - are not any different. The only program that visibly works better with the new multi-core CPU's is the Sonar program I referenced. There is also the built in OS controlled "Core Parking" that will "park" some cores depending on what is happening (there is a way to disable core parking).
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3


    Quote Originally Posted by ProtoType View Post
    I thought the whole thing with i5 was to be able to run two things at the same time at same speeds?
    You couldn't be more wrong ... THE IDEA of multi-core processor is to run as many things as fast as possible as the same time.

    Why does the extracting slow down on both?
    Because, first extraction already uses as many cores as possible, i.e. 4. then you start extracting other file, so it gets 2 cores from first extraction, and you get average time, its simply as 2+2 plus its more about hdd's speed, you should buy ssd to get real speed.

    Am I not understanding how the quad processors work?
    It's quad-core, not quad-processor...
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4


    Posts : 1,875
    Windows 10 Pro Prieview x64


    [QUOTE=startas;167024]
    Quote Originally Posted by ProtoType View Post
    plus its more about hdd's speed, you should buy ssd to get real speed.
    Exactly. Your bottleneck here is not processor it is IO. If you are decompressing a file then the IO subsystem will push data to the cpu as fast as it can and then write out the result. Generally your input file will be contiguous. The write is less interesting as normally it is buffered.

    If you try to unzip 2 at the same time your disk is thrashing reading from file A, then B which are physically in different places on the disk. You'll get the same issue but less with ssd. It will always be quicker to unzip A and then B than both together if you only have one drive.

    There is no way you will use 100% cpu unzipping a file as IO subsystem will never be able to supply the data fast enough on a normal PC.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5


    Posts : 179
    Windows 8.1 Pro x64 with Media Center


    WinRAR's extraction can only use 1 core while its compression uses all cores. Someone correct me if I'm wrong: so even if you open 2 instances of WinRAR and extract 2 files, those two instances will have to share the same core (as extraction is not multi-threaded) and therfore slows your extraction down.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #6


    Posts : 179
    Windows 8.1 Pro x64 with Media Center


    The best way to test this is to monitor the CPU usage of your i5. If extracting 2 things simultaneously only gives ~ 25-30 % CPU, WinRAR obviously is putting 2 processes in the same core thus explaining the slowness you get.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #7


    Posts : 1,875
    Windows 10 Pro Prieview x64


    No, you are wrong. If CPU is 25% what does that mean? What it does not mean is that one core is used. And if it is 30% how is that one core? One and a bit cores? No it means the CPU is not being given enough work.

    The way CPU subsystem works, very simply, is that the job dispatcher (not WinRAR or any user process) will place a piece of work where (with a bit of luck) it will finish quickest. It is not that simple as it may look forward in the instruction chain to guess this. Neither you or I can do this - it is on the chip. If you think WinRAR can specify which core it would like to use then you are incorrect.

    In any case for IO bound (that is where RAM or CPU is not causing the issue) you will never see CPU at 100%. If you see CPU at 100% then your performance issue is either with IO or memory.

    In the case of disk thrashing or in fact any non computational process it is not the CPU.

    Forget cores unless your CPU utilisation is close to 100% for your task. For a PC doing non scientific tasks (or perhaps compilation etc) it will not be. Certainly for unzipping a RAR it is IO.

    Although I could be completely wrong as I'm making assumptions and have not tested it. This is based on larger systems I work on.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #8


    Thanks for the replies, Much helpful!
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #9


    Posts : 1,875
    Windows 10 Pro Prieview x64


    Do one at a time. Also if you are copying large files - copy the first then the second, not both together. If you don't (assuming you have input files only on one drive) your disk arm will be going up and down and just not providing the data required.

    Applies to any small PC system where files are not split over multiple disk arms. Not a Win 8 issue really.

    cheers, adam
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  10. #10


    Quote Originally Posted by fireberd View Post
    But to answer your question, I don't see any difference on most programs between the old Q6600 CPU system I had and the new systems I have - one with an i7 3770 and the other with an i5 3550. .
    so how come I get around 7k ppd with a q6600 and 29k with a i7 2600k ? the i7-2600k proceed 4 time more than the old q6600 in folding. Photoshop will proceed image twice faster with the Sandy Bridge vs Q6600 and Video Encoding is 3 time faster on the Sandy compare to the q6600, I can't see how you don't see a difference.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
i5 Extracting and WinRar
Related Threads
Hi, any help would be appreciated, Trying to install ENVI 5.0 which in the case of this installation uses a self extracting executable. When attempting to install the extraction scrolls to 100% then pops up a "7 Zip" error stating that, "The specified file cannot be found." Running as...
Solved WINRAR and UAC in Software and Apps
Hi guys, I get errors when I try to extract .zip files using WinRAR so I tried the right click Run as Administrator and it worked fine. Unfortunately when I use WinRAR context menus the Run as Administrator option is not possible. So I went into Properties>Compatibility>Settings and checked...
Recently, I've discovered that my system restore does not work. I thought it was due to errors with the specific restore points that I'd tried, but it also failed with a test restore point I'd created. The error can be found below. 46051 I would very much like to fix this issue before the...
WinRAR VS 7zip in Software and Apps
Hello, I was wondering what is the best compression software. I am looking for the following: -Fast at opening ZIP files -Fast at compressing ZIP files -Fast and extracting ZIP files
A video rar file i extracted then it's automatically hiding...pls help http://oi50.tinypic.com/29agqo.jpg http://oi49.tinypic.com/17phlf.jpg http://oi48.tinypic.com/1euamu.jpg Empty folder have memory !!
Winrar extracting issue in Software and Apps
My problem is quite unique since I've been searching the internet and no one had a similar problem. This video will show what my problem is: Winrar Glitch - YouTube So as you can see from the video, I 1) Opened a winrar file, 2) Drag and dropped the file onto the desktop, and a bunch of...
Solved Winrar x64 in Software and Apps
Hi I am running Windows 8 Pro x64 and have problems regarding installation of Winrar x64 version 4.20 and 4.11. Well the problem is that it wont start the installation at all. Nothing happens when i double-click to install the app and event viewer isnt recording the event at all. Anyone got an...
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook