Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums


Should I switch my other PC's to 8?

  1. #1


    United States
    Posts : 650
    Windows 8.1 Pro, iOS 7.1, Elementary OS

    Should I switch my other PC's to 8?


    My main is already 8, while my other 3 test computers are all XP. I know how XP won't be supported soon, but what do you guys think?

    Thanks, friends!

    512 GB of RAM
    (will I need to upgrade RAM to 1 GB?)

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2


    Well, it's only $40 a piece to upgrade them, so $120 is certainly the cheapest route in the past few years. If you don't really use the other computers all of the time though, I'm not sure that I would bother upgrading them. Sure XP only has support for a few more years, but will you really still be using these older machines in a few years?

    I never upgraded my wife's laptop from Vista to 7, and I don't plan to move it to 8. Vista is still working fine and nothing is really broken. No sense in taking a chance to make things worse.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3


    India
    Posts : 1,184
    Windows 8.1, Windows 7, Linux Mint 14


    I would highly recommend upgrade in this case. If you were running W7, I wouldn't have said that. But W8 is better than XP any day. Not only do you have good support but you will find that you are able to run a lot of new programs which are incompatible with XP. I don't consider W8 better than 7. It's different and I love it. At the same time I love 7 as much as I do 8. But since you are running XP and not 7 and upgrade price is just $40, go for the upgrade. Plus, W8 is very light, I mean it doesn't use up much resources, it would run very smoothly in your XP machines. I think the 32 bit version might run with 512 MB RAM.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4


    Solo.
    Posts : 2,159
    Windows 10 Pro 64-bit


    The hardware specification might help deciding whether to or not. System with 512mb RAM, or processors that older than dual core may be better stick to XP till it is really ended. Running Win 7 or 8 with less than 2 GB RAM is actually OK but we may have it occasionally slowing down. I still have few systems with Pentium 4 and 1 gb RAM running XP for normal office works.

    Kevin
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5


    Posts : 5,707
    Windows 8.1 Pro


    I'd plop a gig into those systems as 512 is anorexic these days. Overall, I'd say yes, go for it as Windows 8 actually runs nicer on xp era machines than xp. No joke. Graphically is better, personalization is better, and performance is fairly clean and will probably breathe a breath of fresh air into those puters. Another consideration would be is if those machines are used often enough to justify the upgrade. My personal suggestion would be to try and partition the hard drives and dual boot the machines with xp and 8 to see if the graphics drivers in Windows 8 will work properly with the older hardware. I've come across an elder HP machine that was built in 2005-6 and its graphics driver works great in Windows 7 as the driver is supported by Windows Updates and displays the proper native screen resolution. In 8, everything works fine except that the driver from 7 doesn't install as it claims it isn't digitally signed or I think wasn't supported. So, it could only display in three non-native screen resolutions. But on another xp machine that was vista ready (theoretically as it only has 512 MB of RAM) everything worked fine and ran fine. Actually I retract my first sentence. If the machines are used for light work scenarios such as Office and interwebsting, and Windows 8 runs fine on them as well, you could probably skimp out the extra RAM as I remember Windows only taking about 200 or so MBs of RAM, and this was with Office apps and other things running as well.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #6


    Quote Originally Posted by Arpan View Post
    Not only do you have good support but you will find that you are able to run a lot of new programs which are incompatible with XP.
    However, if these are 3 older computers that you don't really use much, and are light in resources anyway (512MB of RAM), are you really going to install many new apps and try to use them? It really depends to me upon what the user does with their primary computer and how powerful it is. I'll be honest, I rarely, if ever use my old AMD dual core box with 4GB of RAM and my Nvidia 7600GT, when I have my new quad core box with 8GB of RAM and my SSD's and my Nvidia 570GTX. So, that old computer runs XP and more or less runs my scanner which doesn't have a 32bit driver and is used occasionally by my kids to play around on the web. There really isn't a compelling reason whatsoever to spend $40 on that hardware. I would prefer to put the $40 towards either a new computer or parts for my existing higher end box.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #7


    Manchester CT
    Posts : 693
    Windows 8.1 Pro 64 bit GA


    Win8 has a low footprint on the computers so you should not have to worry about doing any substantial memory or CPU upgrades. I plan to move all of my machines over soon but I am in the same quandary: they are running fine as they are, why bother?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #8


    Posts : 1,925
    Windows 8.1 Pro


    It depends, you should run the hardware upgrade advisor on those computers. If you run the setup program you should be able to run the advisor.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #9


    United States
    Posts : 650
    Windows 8.1 Pro, iOS 7.1, Elementary OS


    Thanks!
    My plan is to dual-boot and test the drivers, although one of the computers wont use games already.

    1 GiB coming soon, to 3 computers near me!
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Should I switch my other PC's to 8?
Related Threads
I can't switch to MS account? in User Accounts and Family Safety
44840
Is it possible to switch out SDD's? in Installation & Setup
I was wanting to dual boot Win7 and Win8 but I just want to switch out the SDD's to this. Is this possible? Or will the secure boot thing mess up the Win8 installation?
EIGHT - Switch to Seven in General Support
I posted 2 days ago but its gone~ Here we go again. Asus q200 - laptop running 2013 Office and Win 8. Totally frustrating. So, can we change from 8 to 7? Also, how do we set up Win 7 start up to do away with the wide screen thing? We understand we compromise/lose the ability to use...
I cant switch users in User Accounts and Family Safety
I cant log on to any users but the local administrator. I cant even go under and make changes to the other accts. Any ideas ? I am not very computer savvy.
I currently have everything (windows 8 login, Xbox live, etc) linked to a myname@gmail.com account. I want to switch it all over to myname@outlook.com. How can i do this? I was able to move skydrive and my Windows login, but I can't move my xbox account :( And no, I no longer have an Xbox.
On my HP Envy h8-1414, would there be any advantage to switching from the factory insatalled Win 8 rt to Pro? Thank you.
Switch from Mac OS X in General Support
I used to hate Windows for many years, because it was ugly, slow and unstable. However I liked the look of Windows 8 and it is faster than Mac OS X. I am very pleased by the modern look of the Metro UI and like the mix of Metro and Desktop. However I just cant stand the remaining pieces of AERO. It...
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook