Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums


What's the Point of Start Menu for NON Touch Screen PC?

  1. #21


    South Coast NSW, Australia
    Posts : 615
    Windows 8.1 'Ultimate' RTM 64 bit (Pro/WMC).


    the All Apps page has the same functionality as the start menu.
    I'm using it.

    It doesn't. Not yet, anyway. But the 8.1 incarnation is an improvement.

    And, as I said, you no longer need go through the Start Screen to get to it, which is a plus.


    Wenda.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #22


    Posts : 1,925
    Windows 8.1 Pro


    Quote Originally Posted by chrisa View Post
    The walled garden style interface that Apple came up with is meant to evolve Content Consumption, not Content Creation. It is literally the next broadcast medium. Content Consumption involves 'flipping channels', and as such.. its natural to move from one consumable program to the next this way. Just like browsing websites.
    False. There is nothing inherently preventing anyone from creating content in Metro. In fact, there are many apps that do so. Please explain how this is impossible. For example, the OneNote Metro app is quite good at creating content. I can even shove it off into a corner and use it whenever I want to while i'm using other apps. I can alt-tab between it and anything else i'm doing. I can create as much content as I want.

    Or how about an app like this:

    Brainstorming using Mind Maps

    Guess what? That's a Metro app. Gee, I wonder how that's possible since you insist you can't create content in Metro.

    Oh, hey.. look at this..

    PowerDirector Mobile - Get Started | CyberLink

    You can even edit your videos in Metro, wow! But you said that can't be done!

    Face it, you keep repeating the same crap, and it's still as false as the first time you said it. There is nothing inherently that prevents content creation in Metro, it's just that the apps are not yet mature enough in most cases. That's the only problem. Well, that and the API's are not mature enough for many tasks either.. 8.1 is fixing some of that, with 5000 new API's.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #23


    Posts : 302
    Windows 7 on the desktop, Windows 8 Surface Pro mobile


    Quote Originally Posted by Mystere View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by chrisa View Post
    The walled garden style interface that Apple came up with is meant to evolve Content Consumption, not Content Creation. It is literally the next broadcast medium. Content Consumption involves 'flipping channels', and as such.. its natural to move from one consumable program to the next this way. Just like browsing websites.
    False. There is nothing inherently preventing anyone from creating content in Metro. In fact, there are many apps that do so. Please explain how this is impossible.
    I didn't say it was impossible. I said that was not what it was intended for. Any more than Google Docs being an ideal way to build a spreadsheet.

    Quote Originally Posted by Mystere View Post
    You can even edit your videos in Metro, wow! But you said that can't be done!
    Once again, never once said it couldn't be done. That's your brain running off the rails. You can write a book on a bathroom wall. That doesn't mean its the ideal place to do so, was originally intended for that purpose, or that we should all have to write books on a bathroom wall.. because well.. you can.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #24


    Hmmm - now that I've played with it enough to have some familiarity with it, I don't "hate" the Metro screen - I honestly can't see it being worth my time to use it. Give me a good enough reason and I'll use it.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #25


    Posts : 79
    Win8.1 Pro 64bit


    I still don't see any valid argument against the metro start screen other than emotion. I use Win7 at work and Win8 at home. Switch back and forth without my brain having a fit. Almost anything any one is doing will be on the desktop any way. If you need access to programs frequently then pin, shortcut, and or dock them. Just about every computer person I know that has to work on their computer fills their desktop with shortcuts, docs, files, etc anyway. Having the start menu or start screen wouldn't really seem to make any difference in work flow. If you need to find some thing quicker most of us just launch the search and type or the run command and type. There's also windows explorer that will give you access to everything in the similar way the start menu did.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #26


    Sloe Deth, Californicatia
    Posts : 3,908
    Windows 8 Pro with Media Center/Windows 7


    Quote Originally Posted by Dirty Butter View Post
    I'm using the Classic Shell Start program on the Desktop, which makes the Desktop fully functional for me. But my quandary is what do I miss if I never go look at the Metro screen at all? I don't mind it being there, lurking behind the scenes, but what does Microsoft really expect me to do with it if my equipment isn't touch?

    To be blunt - You are missing NOTHING. Stick with the Desktop, ignore the other thing.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #27


    Mystere, now you have the gall to tell me what "horrid" means to me?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #28


    Covington, La
    Posts : 1,184
    Windows 7 HP 64bit, Windows 8.1 Pro w/Media Center 64BIT


    Quote Originally Posted by Dirty Butter View Post
    Hmmm - now that I've played with it enough to have some familiarity with it, I don't "hate" the Metro screen - I honestly can't see it being worth my time to use it. Give me a good enough reason and I'll use it.
    That is something you need to determine for yourself. I have mine organized for me and I never did like the old Start Menu. I hated looking through folders trying to remember where some lightly used program shortcut was located. I think the 8.1 changes make it somewhat better but its still a personal choice.

    Jim
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #29


    Hafnarfjörður IS
    Posts : 4,376
    Linux Centos 7, W8.1, W7, W2K3 Server W10


    Quote Originally Posted by Mystere View Post
    How, exactly, is it "horrid"?

    It's funny, but every time I ask this question of the start screen haters, all they can do is mumble something about not being designed for a keyboard and mouse, which is patently untrue.
    Hi there
    It really is HORRID if you have to endlessly scroll leftwards for about 7 KM to find something -- and if you install an application every wretched little .EXE file creates a stupid tile which can get inserted ANYWHERE on the start screen -- not necessarily within the main application - and often these .exe files aren't actually the executables you want to start anyway. (And please don't say use the SEARCH -- you might not know or can't remember the name - especially if it's a sub application that you don't use very often).

    No for anybody who has more than two or three LARGE COMPLEX applications that used to require a lot of SUB menus, SUB SUB menus and even SUB SUB SUB menus in the old classical interface the new Metro one is HORRIBLE, B/S and absolutely NOT DESIGNED for convenient use.

    I suspect that there are whole slews of people on this Forum who just can't get it through their brains that some people DO run very complex applications --try installing the full versions of the whole ADOBE CS SUITE together with the FULL version of VISUAL STUDIO and now tell me that the Metro interface is easy to use compared with the old MENU system.

    If you have simple applications or not many applications then it's easy to see where you are coming from -- but you need to try installing the LARGE complex applications to UNDERSTAND what a lot of users have difficulty with -- we aren't being perverse --it's just that this NEW interface makes it a pain to organise after W8 is installed and what is frustrating is that a lot of people just can't SEE THIS. (Of course most people don't have the full CS suite or Visual studio installed so they will never get to see what the problem is anyway).

    Even on a modest laptop the start screen gets a HIDEOUS mess -- I know it can be (eventually) tidyed up but why should I have to go through all that extra totally UNNECESSARY work just to get a system to work as it USED TO straight out of the box.

    Even here scroll towards Infinity (as shown) on screenshot --afraid my infinity symbol isn't too well drawn.

    Old menu system handled this MUCH BETTER.

    And BTW even on a MOBILE PHONE I get fed up with the tiles if I have to scroll more than about 3 or 4 times so even here once you start adding loads of apps the whole interface isn't really fit for purpose even on THOSE devices either.

    Cheers
    jimbo
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails desk.png  
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  10. #30


    Posts : 1,925
    Windows 8.1 Pro


    This is why the start screen is arrangeable. When a program is installed, the normal start menu items are pinned to default locations. You are free to organize them any way you wish. You can name your icon groups to make it easier to find (particularly when using semantic zoom). If you just live with the default locations, and never both to organize it yourself, then I can understand your point, but the start screen has mechanisms to solve all your arguments.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
What's the Point of Start Menu for NON Touch Screen PC?
Related Threads
As you guys know Windows 8's "Start Menu" button is changed to go to "Start Screen", and right clicking the button goes to the WinX menu. Just a simple question, is it possible to make left click goes to WinX menu, and right click goes to Start Screen? Just a reverse version of what is existing.
When I right-click on something on the Start Screen, the customize menu doesn't appear. One day it just stopped appearing, and I don't know why. It's the same if I want to pin something to it from the page with All Apps. I've uploaded a screenshot where I right-clicked on the "Food & Drink" app....
I installed the new Windows 8.1 Service Package 1 update earlier today. I was loving it. They finally got to addressing how bad Windows 8 was for laptops. However, the new context menu in the Start Screen simply does not appear anymore. It was earlier, and I have made no significant changes to the...
Is the any way to add the option to shut down the computer to the little menu that pops up when you click your name on the start screen? The one that displays change account picture, lock, and sign out. I've searched around, but can only find how to add a shutdown tile to the start screen or a...
An elderly relative of mine recently got a new laptop with Windows 8. I had suggested she get one with Windows 7 as she has been using XP for about 8 years. But with various hardware requirements she ended up getting a laptop with Windows 8. Well, getting her accustomed to Windows 8 was a real...
The HP Slate 500 has a keyboard button that on Windows 7 launched the annoying floating keyboard and another which opened the start menu. On Windows 8 it does not do anything, I want to map these buttons so they work again. Does anyone know the command invoked when you hit the Keyboard Toolbar?...
I am trying to get back to the start menu with a touch screen on my convertible tablet. Let's say I'm browsing the internet. If I hit the "windows" key, I can immediately switch to start screen. But what if I don't want to use the (physical) keyboard at all? What's the equivalent from the touch...
Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook