Ok here is the situation.
I noticed yesterday on my WD Green drive some data was slow to read e.g. excessive time to start playing video file, and at same time was read errors logged in SMART so decided to order 2 new drives and move the data.
Today I got the drives, swapped some cables round as one of my red's I realised was on the asmedia controller and I want all my red's on the intel controller, and installed the 2 new WD red drives.
For reference here is the setup
Samsung 850 pro ssd - system drive
WD Black 640 gig
2 Existing WD red 3TB
2 New WD red 3TB
WD green 2TB
Out of case temporarily due to lack of SATA ports
Now today something unexpected happens, I am sorting out the data that will be going to the new redundant setup and suddenly I notice when trying to play a video stored on the hdd the hdd light is on all the time and the video isnt loading, task manager reports a constant high speed been read (in this case 140megabyte/sec). Explorer gets the not responding status, and killing it stops the i/o. I repeat and same file again same issue. I deleted the file. After checking over some other files same problem again on another file, I discovered tho after leaving it 20 minutes the video did actually start playing. Now some more weirdness, it seems I only have to highlight the file in explorer for the everlasting i/o, I dont even need to try and load the file, so selecting a bad file is enough for a constant hdd light and high hdd activity.
So I ran a chkdsk scan, no errors.
Now running a chkdsk forced bad sector scan /R flag and its reading most sectors quickly, but some are pausing for extremely long times, e.g. sector 1935 took over 30 minutes to read, I am watching the smart data whilst this is going on and no error counters are budging, so no reallocated sectorsm no raw read error rate, no calibration errors. Also no weird noises from the hdd. The scan has a ETA of 4 hours to finish So will be a while to see what it reports.
So it seems I was planning to just remove a 2TB drive but a quite new 3TB is acting like its dieing. (7 months old). I may have been lucky in the past but I have never had a HDD in any of my pc's have issues before at such an age, Ironically only yesterday I had no such issues in the same directory as I was only in the same folder yesterday assessing what I would do with the data.
As to the data I have data in one of 2 groups.
1 - Data I can afford to lose, I just redownload it, so things like games of steam, downloaded youtube videos and other stuff which is still on the internet to download.
2 - Data that would be annoying to lose and either hard to get back or impossible. Alot of this data is already on redundant storage. But not all of it.
To maximise efficiency of hdd space since I am not made of money I have the 2 existing reds on a dynamic disk setup. They both have a mirrored 750gig partition for important data, and rest of space as individual partitions for data in group #1. Some #2 data is on the drive I have issues reading from now, also some is on the wd green drive, always planned to move to a mirrored partition, but up until day wasnt actioned.
Today was also when I was going to start doing active backups as well, probably online backups. My really important data like work stuff and emails is already backed up, plus all that is also on the mirrored storage as well. Also to add save game files are also backed up I use steam save game manager for that,
I am annoyed that it looks like I am going to have to replace at least one of the 7 month old RED's already.
I am curious tho is there other possible causes of what I am seeing other than HDD failure, as typically on failures I associate weird noises from the drive and/or SMART failures, which neither is happening.
One of the RED's was previously on the asmedia (dont know which tho off hand), so is it possible e.g. moving a drive that was formatted and written to on the asmedia to the intel cause it to struggle to read the data? I dont think its the sata cable as it was the same files consistently been an issue, not random and not all files either.