Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

FCC approves Net Neutrality rules

  1. #11

    St. Augustine
    Posts : 388
    windows 8.1 64, LT -Windows 10 Home 64

    Quote Originally Posted by Rocky View Post
    I was under the impression that this law would make it tough for small "mom and pop" websites to compete with larger websites. My understanding is that this law kind of equalizes the payment scale for all web servers, thus smaller sites will have to take on the burden of supporting larger web sites. That was my take, but I could be wrong.
    That's exactly what Verizon, ATT and Comcast want you to think. That way they can charge a premium for preferred access and speed.

    With the rapidly expanding dependence on the internet and continued movement to paperless everything the internet must be regulated like an essential utility. Power Generation has been regulated for longer than I can remember and the Power Companies have and continue to do quite well.

    I think it is interesting which FCC members who voted against it.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #12

    Comparing internet regulation to power regulation is a bad analogy. Power companies have a monopoly on providing power because no one is going to build separate power plants and power lines in order to compete, so some amount of regulation is needed to make sure they don't rake their customers over the coals.

    Internet can be gotten via phone lines, coaxial lines and satellite, so there is gauranteed competition.

    Personally, I think it's stupid to be enthusiastic about government bureacrats meddling in how the internet is run. If you like the internet as it is now, why would you want government involvement?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #13

    St. Augustine
    Posts : 388
    windows 8.1 64, LT -Windows 10 Home 64

    Quote Originally Posted by yu gnomi View Post
    Internet can be gotten via phone lines, coaxial lines and satellite, so there is gauranteed competition
    Yes, and a handful of the major corporations control the bulk of it.

    Quote Originally Posted by yu gnomi View Post
    Personally, I think it's stupid to be enthusiastic about government bureacrats meddling in how the internet is run.
    And in the future, I will refrain from those types of comments if you will.

    We are dealing with fair and equal access. I dare say that over the years the government has invested untold billions into the internet through subsidies, grants, tax breaks and the like. The people are the government and the people have a reasonable right to fair and equal access to this indispensable tool.

    This is about making as much money as possible, make no mistake about it.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #14

    Just wandering, what does that mean for others than USA ?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #15

    Hafnarfjörður IS
    Posts : 4,374
    Linux Centos 7, W8.1, W7, W2K3 Server W10

    Hi therte

    Outside the US competition (at least in W.Europe) seems to be working fine -- even in the UK which probably is more like the US in business models and practices than most other EU / EEA countries.

    You can get some very good UNCAPPED (I.e Unlimited) deals on decently fast broadband in the UK these days -- some for ZERO (you only pay around 25 USD for "Line Rental") . --Talk Talk, Virgin, B.T, SKY are 4 UK providers who are doing this --. there may be more.

    Monopoly is usually ALWAYS bad when it's not what one might call a "Natural Monopoly" such as utilities for Water, Gas, Electricity - although even here a "Free Market" can "Sort of work".

    We also have to remember that if Corporations DON'T make money who will supply jobs, infrastructure, R&D investment and funds to provide for people's Pensions etc. The trick is in managing this type of activity so Corporations are part of a RESPONSIBLE community rather than just going all out for sheer GREED. Not an easy one which is why Politicians exist as well - as there are all sorts of ways of managing or mis-managing this type of stuff.

    From most of my travels over the world usually where there is a Monopoly situation works bad for the majority of the consumers of a service apart from those who work in it.

    If people like COMCAST are horrible then other services should be allowed to compete with them and let the market decide.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #16

    Harrisonburg, Va.
    Posts : 10,488
    Windows 8.1.1 Pro with Media Center

    Just my opinion---

    Whenever Government sticks their finger in something it ends up fubar.{or snafu}

    There is a reason acronyms exist.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #17

    In Serbia, we had until recently (5 years ago) monopoly form of PTT (Post, Telephone and Telegraph), government owned company that was sole "Importer" of internet and all the providers had to use their facilities and internet links. Ever since their monopoly was reduced, many new providers with their own links to "outside world of internet" sprung up, some still using that infrastructure (ADSL) but most their own, including TV cable companies. Since then Internet network grew up many times over, with many new, independent providers. Our version of "net neutrality" is regulated by law only in context of PTT, the rest (private companies) are left to do as they please and very rarely you can feel some "chocking" of services like IPTV. I have one internet provider but can stream from 3 IPTV providers and one of them is from directly competing internet provider which is handy because there are only 10 or so real, over the air TV stations.
    No less than 4 mobile phone providers and few stationary but wireless phone operators have their own 3G internet networks with 4G only now starting up. BUT (capital letters intentional) internet service is nothing to write home about, averaging 15/2 Mbps so all that "internet freedom" didn't bring much in terms of speed and price.
    There are some talks in parliament to label internet as "Essential service", like electricity, telephone and TV service (meaning they can't be withheld from and have to be to anyone) but with today's conditions I'm not holding my breath. With all of that, there's estimated only about 60% of households permanently connected to internet although there are twice as much active mobile phones numbers as grown up inhabitants.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #18

    United States
    Posts : 3,093
    Windows 8.1 Pro 64-bit

    The problem in the States is we used to break up monopolies, now the bigger and more controlling one corporation is over a service, the better.
    I don't trust corporations to do the right thing (maybe less) than I do the government. I always think back to the Canadian Sci-Fi series "Continuum" in these situations. I think it is prophetic .
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #19

    Covington, La
    Posts : 1,181
    Windows 7 HP 64bit, Windows 8.1 Pro w/Media Center 64BIT

    The FCC has posted the rules and at the last minuet have removed the interconnect companies from regulation.
    You local ISP will be regulated but the carriers that carry the data across the world will not be. That way Netflix can cut a deal with a carrier for special service to stream their direct feed across the world to your local ISP and the ISP has to accept it as received. So when your local ISP gets bogged down the FCC will step in and make the ISP increase its bandwidth and YOU will pay the price. Don't you just love Gov cluster****s.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
FCC approves Net Neutrality rules

Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Net Neutrality: Obama's Plan for a Free and Open Internet
Source: The White House
Windows 8 News
rules in mail
Windows 8.1 mail app in metro. is there a way to setup rules so that I can set it so messages go into folders. for example there is an facebook folder, orders folder etc I want to setup rules so that all facebook emails go into facebook etc I know you can do this in outlook and...
Browsers & Mail
Where are the Forum Rules?
Is there a link somewhere which shows the Forum rules on what can and can't be posted? For instance this is clearly a rule, and I imagine it would have been in the rules we agreed to when creating our ID, but I didn't take a copy at that point and wondered how to get back to it? I know...
Site Stuff
Deleting all rules at once
Copied my Outlook file to another computer but the rules i have all get in error on the second pc. Since there are a few hundred of them and since i can only deleted one rule at a is the question: Is there a way to remove all the rules fast, maybe in the register? The copied...
Software and Apps
Microsoft contributing to WebKit for html neutrality.
Why is Microsoft contributing to WebKit? - ZDnet I have to say this would be nice. Internet explorer isn't too bad, but there are still a couple things that make it unusable for me. But it's way better than it used to be.
Windows 8 News

Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook