Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

Clean disk before clean install?

  1. #11

    Posts : 59
    Windows 8 PRO 64bit

    thanks theog
    I understand now the part with CLEAN and CLEAN ALL.
    What about the difference between MBR and GPT. My priorities are to avoid complexity for the installation, and an installation that is less likely to cause BSOD.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #12

    Posts : 5,592
    ME, XP,Vista,Win7,Win8,Win8.1

    I personally would stay with GPT.

    It would as good idea to Check the hard drive with the manufacturer's diagnostic tools.
    Last edited by theog; 31 Dec 2012 at 12:42.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #13

    Quote Originally Posted by turboman View Post
    thanks theog
    I understand now the part with CLEAN and CLEAN ALL.
    What about the difference between MBR and GPT. My priorities are to avoid complexity for the installation, and an installation that is less likely to cause BSOD.
    As far as I know, stability is not an issue with MBR or GPT.

    I'm using GPT, but I see no major advantage to it.

    You must use GPT on a drive larger than 2TB. You can only boot from a GPT drive if you have an EFI system rather than a BIOS.

    Apple has been using UEFI on their Intel based Macs far longer than it has been common on Windows machines. A vote of confidence, I suppose.

    Does that confuse things further for you?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #14

    Posts : 5,139
    Win8.1Pro - Finally!!!

    I have done limited work with GPT and don't find any immediate advantages unless you're booting from a disk larger than 2tB.
    IMO it's best to stick with the "tried and true" technology if you're concerned with stability.
    Additionally, you'll find more experience on the forums with MBR than you will with GPT.

    As for BSOD's - I'd suggest that you don't worry about them. They aren't that common (despite your experience) and they are relatively easy to fix in most cases. At work we infrequently get a machine with BSOD's, and it's even more rare to get one that requires my expertise - and I've been doing this for many years (about 25 years of hands on and 10 on the forums)

    Cleaning disks is a choice that you have to make, but in many cases it isn't necessary. If you're happy with the boot process until it gets to Windows - then there's usually no need to clean the disk when reinstalling Windows. BUT, if there's something hidden on the MBR (I'm not that familiar with GPT in this case), then there would be a need to "wipe" the drive with a program that writes 0's on every place on the drive (such as KillDisk or DBAN - both free with a Google search).

    At work we don't wipe disks unless the system has been giving us unexplained problems, and even then we usually just de-allocate the space on the partitions using the Windows installation routine (we delete the partitions). It takes a long time to write 0's across the entire disk, so it's usually reserved for extremely challenging cases.

    Finally, as long as you have the recovery disks, there's no harm in wiping the hard drive prior to installing Windows.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Clean disk before clean install?

Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Checking for Updates hangs after Disk Clean Up
Hello, When I run Check for Updates it just hangs. It says it is checking for updates and green progress bar is repeatedly running across, but nothing happens. Before this problem arose I had just run disk clean-up including remove installation files and windows updates. The disk clean-up...
Windows Updates & Activation
Disk Clean-up - Windows Update Clean-up Stuck.
Greetings, I've done a clean install of Windows 8 + installed all Windows updates. After doing so I ran the disk clean-up tool to remove temp files and saved files from Windows updates, however I have ran into a problem. The disk clean-up tool gets stuck when it reaches the Windows update...
Performance & Maintenance
Clean Windows 8 Install on Blank Disk with no OS
Hi all, My current Windows 7 machine's hard drive is about to fail. I have all the data backed up and I have a new blank hard drive ready to go. I could go into detail on why I can't install Windows 7 to this new hard drive, but that is not what this forum is for. I have a specific question...
Installation & Setup
Clean Installation Win8 Failure (No Disk Space)
I partitioned my hard disk into a 150GB (C) and 500GB (D) and upgraded from Win7 to Win8 (and subsequently Win8.1 after the recent updates). The OS is installed onto the C Drive. Performed a Clean Installation of Win8 on my C Drive. Under the Choose What To Keep Option, I selected Nothing. ...
Installation & Setup
Clean Install
As per topic, I am after doing clean install on my laptop to get rid of bloatware, but there are 2 preinstalled softwares I would like to re-install. How can I do that? Thanks
Installation & Setup
A CLEAN install of windows 8 upgrade after disk wipe.
Hiya there I have a computer running windows 7 (prem) and I am wanting to do a clean install of a retail purchased DVD of windows 8 Pro upgrade. Now I am aware there are tutorials on here telling you how to do that.. deleting partitions etc and I understand them, however as I understand the...
Installation & Setup
New ssd and clean install issues. Not reading disk when booting
Hi everyone I'm a bit of a novice but I decided to upgrade my computer and would love some advice please. I am currently running windows Vista 32 with an Hd and decided to upgrade to a SSD with windows 8 professional 64GB using a clean install. I have watched a few videos which suggest you...
Installation & Setup

Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook