Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

Confusing context menu in Windows 8.1 File Explorer

  1. #1

    Posts : 2
    Windows 8.1

    Confusing context menu in Windows 8.1 File Explorer


    Has anyone else found right-clicking in the file-list in Windows 8 File Explorer confusing? Despite the file under the cursor clearly highlighted, the right-click context menu is for the containing folder - but a left-click at the same spot will select the highlighted file. It works as expected if you right-click on the text, but not if you right-click in the highlighted row.

    I've written up a description and set of screenshots here to show the problem:

    anon31522: Confusing context menu in Windows 8.1 File Explorer

    I can't remember if this was how it worked in 8.0, but I think they've got this wrong.

    Unless I have some flag set somewhere or something....? Don't think so.


      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2

    Posts : 2,627
    win8.1.1 enterprise

    my 8.1 is the same ,and I would assume it because they don't want you to cut the download folder from the list .

    if my take on what you are saying is correct, i will say this ,the download or picture or documents folder in the list is not reoffered to as a file ,its a Folder [shortcut of sorts]to the original folder in you user folder in the root of C:\,that is why it will not show the cut option,
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3

    I don't have 8.1, just 8.0 and it doesn't work that way. When I right click on a folder or file under Downloads and select Properties, I get the properties dialog for what ever file or folder I clicked on.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4

    Posts : 2
    Windows 8.1

    Confusing right click in Windows 8.1 File Explorer

    OK, I have revised my description at the original link to try and be clearer.

    anon31522: Confusing right-click in Windows 8.1 File Explorer

    The confusion happens because the whole row is highlighted under the mouse cursor when using the file list in Detail view (as a list with file name, date, size type etc). Right clicking the file's name (or any text such as size, date, type etc) selects the file and shows the correct context menu as expected, but right clicking in the space on the row for an unselected file - even though it is highlighted - will show the context menu for the containing folder instead.

    Seems pretty unintuitive to me, and keeps catching me out.

    Did they add the highlighting in 8.1? Anyone know if it can be turned off?
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Confusing context menu in Windows 8.1 File Explorer

Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Customise File Explorer Dropdown Menu?
Is it possible to rearrange the content of the File Explorer Dropdown Menu? 55634 I would like to move rename farther away from delete as I sometimes click too quickly and inadvertently delete files.
Performance & Maintenance
How to Disable Upper File Menu in Explorer?
Hi this toolbar appeared in my file explorer after downloading a theme. anyone know how to disable it? where it says File, Home, etc. 55324
Adding print to context menu - Reverse this reg file pls?
I have a small collection of reg files ive been accumulating and theyre always in pairs just in case :P (and until I learn my way around adequately without such - but thats another story). One of which I dont have its "pair" and I find important is the "Print" in context menu option. I have...
Onenote - Add file using Windows right-click context menu
I have Onenote installed on my Windows 8.1 laptop. Is it possible to right click a text document (or any file/document) saved on my laptop and have it sent to Onenote. Onenote does not show when I right click a text document. I have used Evernote before and I'm sure I could do this. ...
Software and Apps
Add search engine option to windows explorer context menu
Hi, I am using windows 8.1 and i wonder whether there is any possibility of adding custom search engines to the windows explorer's context menu. For example, let's say someone wants to check out the plot and rating of a downloaded movie. He would have to visit and search for that...
Windows Defender context menu - scan file(s)/folder(s)?
In reference to this thread here: Is there a way to get a context menu to scan individual files and/or folders like MSE does in Windows 7 and prior?
System Security
annoying context sensitive ribbons in file explorer
7963 I'm really annoyed by the context sensitive ribbons in the file explorer. The constantly change the look (a coloured tab pops up (library tools in this example picture) and the title name moves) from the window when I work with various files. Even when I have minimized the ribbon the tab...
General Support

Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook