Windows 8 and 8.1 Forums

Windows 8.1: My Opinion Elaborated Author: Koroush Ghazi

  1. #1

    Bay Area
    Posts : 21,411
    Windows 7 Home Premium x64

    Windows 8.1: My Opinion Elaborated Author: Koroush Ghazi

    Quite a few people have written to me expressing surprise at, and in many cases, support for, my rather blunt outburst against Windows 8.1, posted earlier in the week. To recap, here is what I posted on 3 September 2013, on the front page of my site:

    Over the last few days I've been quite busy installing and exploring the Windows 8.1 RTM ISO that was recently leaked. I don't normally condone the use of leaked software, but in this case, given it's ultimately a free upgrade, and the fact that I need to get across the changes as soon as possible so I can update the TweakGuides Tweaking Companion for Windows 8, I thought it justified.

    My impression of Windows 8.1 can be summed up in two words: extremely disappointing. The march towards tabletizing a Desktop OS continues, as Windows 8.1 hides or completely removes several potentially useful Desktop features, while gussying up the Metro interface. If you're also not vigilant during installation, you will automatically be opted into using Bing ad-driven searches, SkyDrive integration and a Microsoft Account. The only unambiguously positive changes are the addition of options to boot straight to Desktop, and disable the hot corners, neatly hidden away under the Taskbar Properties>Navigation tab I might add. Fortunately, workarounds exist for some of the changes, and of course Start Menu replacement utilities, along with other Windows 8 customization tools, will provide further options.

    I don't normally like to post opinions, especially negative ones, on the front page. In this case, I can't resist, as this *******ization of Windows makes me quite angry. Having used every version of Microsoft's operating systems since 1988 (MS-DOS 5.0), this is the first time I truly believe that Microsoft has lost its way. To put it bluntly, Windows 8.1 is a mish-mash of interfaces, and in some cases borderline deceptive options, mainly to serve Microsoft's dubious ambitions in the mobile device arena, rather than consumers and businesses. It will only serve to further confuse and alienate the average PC user, and hasten the PC's demise. I've used Windows 8 as my daily OS since the Preview back in June 2012, and I can honestly say it seems like one step forward, four steps back when compared to Windows 7.

    In any case, I am currently detailing all of the changes and attempting to provide revised best practice usage recommendations in an update to the TweakGuides Tweaking Companion for Windows 8. I will release the updated version shortly after the official release of Windows 8.1.

    A Guy

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2

    I agree with him on just about every thing.
    Last edited by labeeman; 12 Sep 2013 at 18:17.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3

    Posts : 27
    Windows Serve 2012 R2

    I urgently and immediately agree with the author of the scripture
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4

    Posts : 5,357
    7/8/ubuntu/Linux Deepin

    Yup. MS still have a lot of clout. They may be able to pull it off. It will be fascinating to see how this all unwinds.

    He doesn't pull any punches:

    Why has Microsoft really done this? Well, having seen the types of profits that companies like Apple have made with their mobile devices and their Walled Garden environments, Microsoft has decided that it too wants a piece of this pie. It is quite obvious that at some point, the decision was made by Microsoft management that users should not be given the option to isolate themselves on the Desktop, and should instead be given no alternative to using the new Metro environment, in the hopes that they will become accustomed to it through lack of choice.
    There will be a (thankfully) very tiny number of people who approve of it.
      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Need you opinion on this?
31869Guys can you tell me how is my laptop..and how is this specs for all heavy games? Screenshot by Lightshot
Your opinion on email security (outlook.exe)
One thing always disappointed me about local email software applications. And that's the password storage. The password is stored locally on your machine. So, I'm sure there are password stealers that will sniff out stored email passwords. That seems to be a huge vulnerability in my...
System Security
Replacement Start Menus - Consensus of opinion
I have been a big advocate of Ex7For8 to restore the traditional Win7 Orb Start Menu, and up until recently it had been OK. But after installing a batch of recent updates, on start up it takes about 30 seconds after the desktop appears before any apps can be run. And when I click on an app/program...
General Support
What is owner opinion on Atom based Win8 tablets?
So I really want to get a Windows 8 tablet but just cannot choose. It seems like everything is a compromise until Intel drops new 7w silicon and OEMs find a sweet spot. I would like a 10.1" Windows 8 tablet that is roughly the size and weight of the iPad. Right now this only seems doable with an...
Drivers & Hardware
Your Opinion: Technology
Your opinion: Overall, does the technology available today make us smarter & well informed or ultimately more dependent on it? I was presented this question by a friend that's in IT. I'd like to get member's input. I have mine, of which I'll post after awhile. Thanks.
General Support
Just tested the opinion of the 'General Public'
Today I gave the last class of an eight week Windows 7 class in my computer club. During the last hour of the class I presented Windows 8 as kind of an outlook. The reaction was interesting. Not a single person disliked Windows 8 at this point. The general consensus was that it is probably easier...
General Support

Eight Forums Android App Eight Forums IOS App Follow us on Facebook